By Gaia Zanotti
Introduction
The British Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has announced the launch in Spring 2027 of a new employer sponsorship scheme, allowing employers to directly sponsor and allow the relocation of eligible refugees to the UK.
To any refugee law scholar, civil society member or refugee rights activist, the opening of legal routes with the promise to allow some refugees to work as soon as they enter the UK is likely to sound like a step in the right direction. And, in a sense, it is, as it represents a softening of the prohibition to work that has characterised the British asylum system since the beginning of the 21st Century. However, it also represents a further entrenchment of an ideological approach to the provision of economic rights to refugees that is problematic and that, as a whole, does not sufficiently account for the humanitarian objectives of international protection regimes.
Why the British framework is even worse than it seems
In the UK, recognised refugees are permitted to work or set up a business with little to no restriction. Asylum seekers who have not yet been recognised as refugees may, under paragraph 360 of the Immigration Rules, apply for permission to work twelve months after their initial application for international protection, provided that any delay in the processing of their application cannot be attributed to them. Asylum seekers who are granted such permission can only engage in employed work, i.e. they cannot be self-employed or set up their own business. They are also limited to working in occupations listed under the Appendix Skilled Occupations (ASO) List, which is intended to highlight sectors or occupations which are experiencing labour shortages, and can only work in a position requiring a level 6 qualification in accordance with the Regulated Qualifications Framework, corresponding to a Bachelors degree. Altogether, Para 360 establishes a highly restrictive framework; and while no official data is provided on how many asylum seekers have been granted this ‘right to work’ or on how many then manage to secure employment, this framework is generally regarded as so restrictive that it amounts to a de facto prohibition to work for all asylum seekers.
The stringent framework of paragraph 360 does not exist in isolation, but is consistent with the overall approach evidenced within the British rules which are very miserly in providing non-nationals with a ‘right to work’. The approach is best summarised in the UK’s reservation to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, interpreting Article 6- i.e. the right to work as ‘not precluding the imposition of restrictions, based on place of birth or residence qualifications, on the taking employment in any particular region or territory for the purpose of safeguarding the employment opportunities of workers in that region or territory’. This, in the context of international protection, means that only recognised refugees are permitted to work, while asylum seekers are excluded from benefitting from any of the rights guaranteed to recognised refugees up until they are established to be deserving of them. The only exception is through paragraph 360, delineated in accordance with the ASO list, which is understood as reflecting labour market shortages and thus performs an economic function relating to labour migration. This means that the overarching attitude of suspicion towards asylum applications, and protective attitudes towards the British labour market, can only be trumped if some economic benefit is identified.
Furthermore, the ability of refugees and asylum seekers to engage with the British labour market is also affected by the fact that migration status is not a protected characteristic under the Equality Act. This means that it is technically permissible for employers to make managerial decisions which disadvantage asylum seekers or refugees when these are not linked to their race, ethnicity or nationality, but their migration status specifically. There may be scope for discussion of the use, legitimacy, and ethical implications of such a rule in the context of labour migration: this could be seen as one component in the complex balancing act of making employment of individuals through certain visa schemes more or less desirable for employers to manage labour supply within the wider labour market context. However, this rule is much less appropriate in the context of international protection and humanitarian, rather than economic, migration.
Why refugees and asylum seekers should not be treated as a source of human capital
Asylum seekers and refugees should not be treated, in terms of the rules which govern their ability to work, in the same way as other categories, especially economic migrants.
The ontological distinction between refugees and economic migrants is a highly contentious one. Its accuracy is disputed as it reflects an essentialist understanding of why people cross borders: with a sharp distinction between forced and voluntary migration, in response to either political persecution or to escape mere poverty. The distinction has also been also criticised as it produces a problematic hierarchization of human suffering, where political persecution should be treated more seriously than violations of socio-economic rights.
Nevertheless, international protection is distinct from other categories of migration on account of its distinctly humanitarian aims, which are manifested in the principle of non-refoulement. And while there is a lot of scope for critiquing the understanding of ‘persecution’ which still permeates international protection regimes, it does not remove the distinct nature of this category of cross-border movement.
Thus, the humanitarian aims of international protection must inform how the work for this group of non-nationals is regulated; and, at a minimum, refugees and asylum seekers should not be treated primarily as a source of human capital. Beyond a legal-normative reason, derived from the principle of non-refoulement or the status of the right to work as a human right, the need for more careful regulation stems from the different ways in which humanitarian migrants interact with the labour market of the host state. In fact, work is not a right that is practiced in isolation, but its exercise is inextricably linked to a pre-existing competition-driven labour market, within which the right to work and the labour rights of national and other non-national workers are also exercised and enjoyed. As refugees and asylum seekers are, by definition, not entering the host state on account of labour market shortage, they will possess reduced expendable human capital in the labour market, making them more susceptible to finding themselves in precarious, low-skill or even exploitative working arrangements. This can accelerate processes such as labour market segmentation, and potentially lead to overall precarisation and degradation of labour conditions.
Therefore, the regulation of work for refugees and asylum seekers must somehow incorporate both the humanitarian aims of international protection, , fulfil the obligations in relation to work under the 1951 Refugee Convention and the International Covenant of Economic Social and Cultural Rights, while also being practically viable within the labour market. Ultimately, this issue lies at the intersection of competing interests and conflicting principles which are difficult to reconcile or even rank. Nevertheless, this does not mean this issue should be overlooked, since work is such an important facet of individual life and identity including for asylum seekers and refugees. However, it is also crucial to do right, as states should at least attempt to manage the entry of this group of non-nationals in the labour market in such a way as to safeguard their economic rights and the rights of all other workers. Therefore, the humanitarian nature of international protection must somehow be balanced with the economic needs of the labour market, but must also be such as to honour the status of work as a human right, rather than merely be informed by economic factors or the current conditions of the labour market.
What rules should be put in place instead
The implicit acknowledgement within the Home Secretary’s proposal that refugees and asylum seekers are individuals with a capacity to contribute to the host society and economy is something to welcome. However, the pursuance of economic utilitarian aims in the way work is governed in the context of international protection is not.
While it is not the intent of the author to dismiss the significant complexities of regulating work in the context of international protection, this should be at the very least internally consistent with the basic norms and objectives of the two regulatory domains it intersects with: labour law and international refugee law. Given how restrictive the British rules have been since 2002, it is time for the British regulatory framework to start treating humanitarian migrants as such. Instead of doubling down on the effort to make the right to work of refugees and asylum seekers contingent on an identified economic benefit, the Home Secretary could leverage the current impetus for change to produce a framework which at least attempts to incorporate and balance all the relevant principles. This could be understood in terms of meaningful labour market participation: both honouring the status of work as a right, in accordance with the non-economic nature of international protection, while also making the exercise of such a right viable within the current labour market. This would look like ensuring that refugees and asylum seekers benefit from socio-economic rights; encouraging them to participate in social dialogue through trade union membership, providing them with specialised training or English language courses, taking measures to avoid degradation of skills, and in general protecting their right to seek and engage in a freely chosen occupation. All considered, while the details of the forthcoming scheme are yet to be revealed, merely establishing an employer-driven resettlement route for established refugees is not a meaningful change to the asylum rules, and is not going to benefit those who claim asylum in the UK. The proposal is still the continuation of a misguided and possibly illegitimate effort to maintain a separation between asylum and labour migration while also making access to employment contingent on an identified economic contribution.
Gaia Zanotti is a PhD candidate in Law at University of Edinburgh. Her doctoral research examines the regulation of work in the context of international protection through a labour law framework.
The views expressed in this article belong to the author/s and do not necessarily reflect those of the Refugee Law Initiative. We welcome comments and contributions to this blog – please comment below and see here for contribution guidelines.